Skip to main content

Is It Lyme Disease or Multiple Sclerosis (MS)?


Lyme disease is caused by Borrelia burgdorferi, a spirochete that is transmitted by the deer tick. The spirochete can be transmitted to humans or animals through the bite of a tick, with Lyme disease symptoms appearing in days or months. Moreover, 60%-80% of patients with Lyme disease get a big, crimson rash that looks like a bull’s eye. A flu-like illness with fever, headaches, a stiff neck, and muscle and joint discomfort are among the other symptoms.

Lyme disease can cause delayed neuropsychiatric symptoms such as weakness, blurred vision due to optic neuritis, dysesthesias (sensations of itching, burning, stabbing pain, or "pins and needles"), confusion, cognitive dysfunction, and fatigue, which are similar to those seen in multiple sclerosis (MS). Lyme disease symptoms can come and go in a relapsing-remitting pattern. Lyme disease can also cause additional abnormalities that are comparable to those found in MS, such as positive findings on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) analyses.

Because of the similarity in symptoms and test findings, some people with MS have requested testing for Borrelia antibodies to evaluate if their neurologic problems are caused by Lyme disease or MS. The distinction is crucial because Lyme disease often responds to antibiotic medication, especially when treated early on, but MS does not.

Several medical conditions can have similar symptoms. Feeling tired, dizzy, or weak; experiencing numbness or tingling in the hands and feet; or experiencing the onset of vision problems can occur because of MS or Lyme disease. However, these symptoms occur because of different conditions and have different causes and treatments. An accurate diagnosis requires ruling out the other option.


What does the research on Lyme disease and multiple sclerosis say?

The overlap between MS and Lyme disease diagnoses was investigated in two trials. The research was performed in areas of Long Island, New York, where Lyme disease is endemic or occurs often.

In the first trial, patients with Borrelia antibodies in their blood and various "MS-like" neurologic symptoms were assessed using MRI, evoked potentials (EP), and CSF analysis, which included a test for Borrelia antibodies in the spinal fluid.

While individuals with MS-like symptoms had the most aberrant MRIs and were the only ones among those evaluated to have abnormal EP and oligoclonal bands in their spinal fluid (indicating an abnormal immune response), no Borrelia antibody was found in their spinal fluid.

The researchers concluded that the few patients who showed MS-like symptoms were most likely suffering from MS and had also been exposed to the Borrelia bacterium.

In a separate study, researchers examined the blood samples of 100 people who had been diagnosed with MS for Borrelia antibodies. Only one out of 89 people who were diagnosed with MS had antibodies against Borrelia. Infection with Borrelia is uncommon in patients with MS who live in an endemic location, the researchers stated. In the differential diagnosis of MS, Lyme disease is unlikely to play a substantial role. Furthermore, the presence of Borrelia antibodies does not indicate that the neurological symptoms are caused by Borrelia; it merely indicates that the organism has been infected previously.


Understanding Lyme disease

Lyme disease is a bacterial infection spread by tick bites from infected black-legged or deer ticks. Ticks aren't naturally infected with the disease. They get it by eating an infected host animal. It is transmitted to people by ticks that adhere to the skin for 36-48 hours and transmit a spirochete bacteria called Borrelia burgdorferi through their bite. Tick populations are concentrated in certain locations of the country. Ticks are more common on the East and West coasts, as well as sections of the Midwest, though ticks can be found across the United States.


Understanding multiple sclerosis

MS is a neurological system disorder caused because the immune system is not working properly. When the immune system mistakenly attacks the myelin sheath, the protective coating protecting nerve fibers, its damages the central nervous system (CNS). Thus, the transmission of information between the brain and the rest of the body is disrupted. Numbness, muscle weakness, discomfort, tremors, balance and mobility issues, exhaustion, bladder problems, speech dysfunction, and other MS symptoms are caused by disruptions in nerve signals, which affect limb movement and sensations of sight and touch.


Why is it so difficult to make an accurate MS diagnosis?

Because there is no single test for diagnosing MS, getting an accurate diagnosis can be difficult. According to the findings of a new study published in the journal Multiple Sclerosis and Related Disorders, roughly one in every five people with various neurologic diseases is misdiagnosed as having MS. Because of the ambiguity, many people suffer from symptoms for months or even years before receiving an official MS diagnosis.

The initial symptoms of both can be similar:

Because the first symptoms of MS and Lyme disease can be similar, doctors use various procedures, including blood and imaging tests, to confirm a diagnosis.

Lyme disease is diagnosed through blood tests:

Your doctor will assess whether you live in or have recently traveled to a region known for the incidence of Lyme disease or the presence of deer ticks as part of the Lyme diagnosis routine. Blood tests are essential for detecting whether the bacterium that causes Lyme disease is present.

Blood tests seek antibodies to Borrelia. The bacterium that causes Lyme disease, Borrelia burgdorferi, can infiltrate practically every organ or system in the body and cause Lyme disease.


Diagnosis of MS using the elimination method:

MS is typically diagnosed by a process of elimination.

Immunologic, environmental, viral, and genetic variables, on the other hand, may all play a role in the development of MS. Because no single approach—blood analysis, spinal tap, MRI, or other test—can definitively diagnose MS, the diagnosis is usually a process of elimination.


Lyme disease symptoms that overlap and differ from MS:

Lyme and MS have several similarities and differences.

Lyme disease affects the neurological system in 10%-15% of cases. In terms of neurologic symptoms and test results, Lyme and MS have a lot in common.

Lyme disease symptoms might begin within days following a tick bite or take months to show. Between 60% and 80% of people with Lyme disease will develop a big, red rash that resembles a bull’s eye, which is one of the classic differentiating factors.

Flu-like symptoms such as lethargy, fever, headaches, swollen lymph nodes, and muscle and joint discomfort are also early markers. People may experience numbness and tingling as the condition worsens, and others may develop cognitive difficulties such as short-term memory loss and speech impairment. Lyme disease, unlike MS, can be successfully treated with medicines if detected early.

Lyme disease can cause delayed neuropsychiatric symptoms that are similar to those of MS. Muscle weakness, blurred vision, itching, burning, stabbing pain or pins and needles, confusion, cognitive impairment, and weariness are some of the symptoms. Lyme disease, like MS, can present symptoms in relapsing-remitting stages, often known as remissions and exacerbations.

Other symptoms of Lyme disease include positive findings on MRI brain scans and CSF test results; however, neurological issues tend to appear earlier in the disease's course. Lyme illness might look similar to multiple sclerosis, but there are some key differences. The most significant distinction is that Lyme disease is a bacterial illness, whereas MS is not; MS is an autoimmune condition.


Treatment objectives for Lyme and MS differ

MS treatment options vary and are aimed at managing symptoms and preventing relapse. Prescription medicines, corticosteroids, and plasma exchange are all used to help control the condition. Fatigue, depression, sexual and bladder difficulties, and other symptoms are treated with physical therapy, muscle relaxants, and other medications. Lyme disease may be treated and is usually cured, whereas MS is a chronic, generally progressive, lifelong condition that can range from being moderate to severe.

Lyme disease after treatment: post-treatment Lyme disease (PTLD)

Lyme disease frequently responds to antibiotic medication, especially when treated early, but MS does not. Lyme disease treatment does not always lead to complete recovery. PTLD symptoms might be unclear and similar to those of other infections. The majority of people, on the other hand, recover and resume their normal lives.


Identifying what isn't working

The symptoms of medical diseases can be similar. Symptoms of MS or Lyme disease include fatigue, dizziness, and weakness, as well as numbness or tingling in the hands and feet and the development of vision issues. Nonetheless, these are two distinct illnesses with distinct causes and treatments. To make an accurate diagnosis, you must rule out everything that isn't working.


Diagnostic blood tests might be perplexing

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends that blood tests be used to look for B. burgdorferi-specific antibodies, which are widely considered the most essential tool for diagnosing Lyme disease. Because it can take weeks for the body to build an immunological response that would result in positive test findings, the test may be negative if the tick bite occurred less than a month ago. When a typical bull’s-eye rash appears but does not develop or is not present in all cases, it is easier to diagnose Lyme disease. When neither MS nor Lyme disease can be definitively diagnosed, the most typical course of action is to closely watch the patient over time to see whether there is any progression or differences in test results.

After early treatment for Lyme disease, the prognosis is usually quite excellent. When diagnosis and therapy are delayed, the prognosis worsens.

Antibiotics help most individuals with early Lyme disease recover and return to their usual state of health. Despite routine antibiotic therapy, some individuals experience chronic or recurrent symptoms due to Lyme disease. The persistent symptoms of Lyme disease can have a significant detrimental effect on a person's health and quality of life. Patients commonly refer to this condition as chronic Lyme disease, even though a clinical case definition for chronic Lyme disease has proven difficult to come across.

Patients with PTLD are those who have been severely ill for 6 months or longer after receiving standard antibiotic therapy for Lyme disease. Severe fatigue, musculoskeletal discomfort, sleep disturbances, depression, and cognitive issues such as difficulty with short-term memory are all signs of PTLD. Because of the lack of a direct diagnostic biomarker blood test, physicians have struggled to identify PTLD, and its presence has been disputed. Our clinical research, on the other hand, reveals that thorough patient evaluation combined with proper diagnostic tests can reliably identify individuals with a history of previously treated Lyme disease who show the usual PTLD symptom patterns.


MS prognosis

There is good and bad news when it comes to the prognosis of MS. MS is a chronic disorder with no cure, even though it isn't fatal.

Many people with MS face additional challenges that might reduce their quality of life. Even though the majority of people will never be seriously incapacitated, many may endure symptoms that cause pain, discomfort, and inconvenience.

MS-related complications, such as infections, cardiovascular illness, and accidents, can shorten a person's lifespan compared with a healthy individual. Treatment for these issues, on the other hand, can considerably lower the likelihood of a shorter lifespan.

The National Multiple Sclerosis Society reports that the average lifespan of people with MS has increased over time. However, the related difficulties shorten the average lifespan of people with MS by around 7 years compared with people who do not have MS.

People with MS die from many of the diseases that people without MS have, such as cancer and heart disease. Besides severe MS cases, which are uncommon, the prognosis for longevity is generally favorable.

The type of MS has an effect on the prognosis. Because each case is unique, there may be periods of inactivity.

MS generally has a greater effect on quality of life than it does on longevity. While certain types of MS may shorten life expectancy, they are the exception rather than the rule.

Patients with MS have to deal with a lot of unpleasant symptoms that have a negative effect on their daily lives. They can be certain, however, that with proper treatment, their life expectancy will be similar to that of healthy people.